< Back to all articles

Latest News

The fascinating letter by Sherlock author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle which remains in Edinburgh to this day
24 May, 2019

The fascinating letter by Sherlock author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle which remains in Edinburgh to this day

There is a fascinating letter written by legendary Sherlock Holmes author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle which remains in Edinburgh to this day - reports Edinburgh Live. 

Exactly 160 years ago today the famous writer was born at an address on the city's Picardy Place – just a stone's throw away from the popular Conan Doyle pub on York Place.

The author went on to create one of the most famous fictional detectives in the world – with his storytelling treasured by millions of Sherlock fans worldwide.

However, an intriguing letter which remains at the National Library of Scotland on George IV Bridge to this day, reveals that his work wasn't always so appreciated.

The note was sent by Conan Doyle in 1882, when he was in his early 20s and before Sherlock had been created, to Blackwood's Magazine in a bid to have his short story 'The Actor's Duel' published.

In the letter he reveals that the publication earlier turned down one of his stories, which was later revealed to be The Haunted Grange of Goresthorpe, and he was hoping his latest work wouldn't suffer a similar fate.

It reads:

"Dear Sir. I venture to submit to your notice the accompanying tale 'The actor's duel'. I once before trespassed upon your valuable time by sending up a sketch which did not come up to your standard – I trust that this may meet with a better fate. However defective the working out may be I am conscious that the denouement is both original and powerful, worthy, I hope, of the traditions of your magazine."

The tale eventually ended up being published under new name The Tragedians in Bow Bells Magazine in August 1884 – so there was once again no luck with Blackwood's.

It tells the story of a Parisian actor who stumbles upon three men trying to abduct his sister after returning home from winning a big role.

He manages to stop the abduction but finds out that one of the men responsible is a colleague and actor who plays the role of Hamlet in the same play.

As a result he challenges him to a duel – and they need to settle it during their next performance.

We'll not spoil the rest, but the story well worth a look – even if Blackwood's Magazine didn't think so.

edinburghlive.co.uk

Other News

5 February, 2024

Holmes Fest 2024

The Conan Doyle Estate are proud to be supporting Holmes Fest 2024. An evening of fun, sketches, poetry and song celebrating the life and times of Arthur Conan Doyle in Portsmouth, and his greatest creation Sherlock Holmes will run on 18th February at the Square Tower, Old Portsmouth.

Read
6 December, 2023

EUP Complete Works of Conan Doyle

The Conan Doyle Estate is helping to sponsor a scholarly edition of Conan Doyle's writing produced by Edinburgh University Press. Three volumes have now rolled off the presses, and three more should follow in 2024.

Read
1 December, 2023

Why Does It Have To Be Original?

An extract taken from 'Only Connect' written by Director of The Conan Doyle Estate and Step Great Grandson of Arthur Conan Doyle - Richard Pooley. Richard was interviewed by historian Lucy Worsley which features in the three-hour, three-episode BBC television documentary on Arthur Conan Doyle, creator of Sherlock Holmes. 'Killing Sherlock'.

Read

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more.

Accept